Saturday, September 12, 2009

Syed Akbar Ali: The Quranic Islam versus the ‘Religion’ of ‘Islam’

By Yoginder Sikand

Born in 1960 Ipoh, Perak, Syed Akbar Ali is a Malaysian of Tamil Muslim (Mamak) origin. He studied business management and engineering in the United States, after which he returned to Malaysia to work as a banker and then served a stint as a Consultant at the National Economic Action Council of the Prime Minister’s Department. He presently runs a jewellery business in Kuala Lumpur. He was also a newspaper columnist for several years, writing mainly about religion, politics and current affairs He has published three books so far: To Digress A Little (2005), Malaysia And The Club of Doom (2006) and Things in Common (2008). He is an activist of the ruling United Malays National Organisation (UMNO).

Ali is not a trained traditional alim, but he assumes that, as a Muslim, it is his right to seek to understand the Quran on his own. A striking feature of Ali’s approach to Islam is his reliance only on the Quran, for, as he argues, God Himself has guaranteed that the Quran shall be protected by Him. The same is not true, he argues, for the Hadith as well as the corpus of fiqh, all of which he dismisses as unreliable. Given that many of the problematic issues in traditional and contemporary Islamic discourse to do with women, non-Muslims, inter-community relations and so forth, have their basis in the Hadith and fiqh, and not in the Quran, Ali’s approach enables him to provide novel answers to such issues without having to engage with the Hadith and fiqh at all.
A second major aspect of Ali’s understanding of Islam is his insistence that Islam is not a religion, in the sense of a cult and a set of beliefs about the supernatural. Rather, it is a complete way of life, ad-din in Arabic, which has been taught by all the many prophets that God has sent to the world, the last of whom was the Prophet Muhammad. ‘Islam’, he points out, simply means ‘to surrender’ to God, and this has been the way life that all the prophets. As he puts it, ‘Islam is not a religion or agama. There is no such thing as a religion of Islam […] Islam is a deen or way of life, a good way of doing things. Deen can also imply an Order—an ordered way of life.’[1] In these two senses, then, he argues, Islam represents true universalism. In contrast, he claims that Muslims have reduced Islam from a way of life to a mere religion, a narrow set of laws and beliefs. In his view, they wrongly understand Islam as a cult that is in fierce completion with other cults for supremacy. In this way, he claims, they are not ‘true’ Muslims, in the literal sense of the term (which means to ‘submit’ to God’s Will). Instead, he generally refers to them as ‘deviationist religionists’[2] and ‘cultists’.
A third significant aspect of Ali’s understanding of Islam relates to the question of Islamic authority. God’s last revelation to humankind, the Quran, he says is for all to study and understand. There is no priesthood in Islam, and hence the class of ulema, who presume themselves to be authoritative interpreters of Islam, functioning almost similarly as priests in other religions, has no basis in the Quran. From this follows the argument that one is not bound to follow the opinion of the ulema, past or present.
A fourth central focus of Ali’s approach is to deconstruct, even dismiss, much of the corpus of what has come to be widely understood as the Islamic shariah. He claims that much of this is actually the invention of the earlier ulema, mixed with what he regards as fabricated Hadith narratives for which there is no reliable historical record, as well as the baneful impact of Jewish and Christian thinking on the early Muslim scholars.[3] In this way, Ali is able to argue that many of the deeply problematic aspects of the historical shariah are simply not Islamic at all, in that they have no sanction in the Quran, which, Ali insists, is the only text that Muslims must rely on.
One of Ali’s principal concerns is the formidable rise of conservative, supremacist and reactionary, groups speaking in the name of Islam, in Malaysia and elsewhere, many of which have taken to violent means. These include, but are not limited to, the principal opposition party in Malaysia, the ‘Islamic’ PAS. He considers them a danger to Islam itself. With regard to such elements in Malaysia, he argues that they are a ‘corrupting influence’, because they are ‘advocating chaos and confusion’ and that they would destroy Malaysia if they are left unchecked. Despite claiming to be champions of Islam, most of them, he says, ‘[do] not possess Islamic values.’ Hence, ‘they just [do] not represent Islam’. In a meeting with the then Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad, chief of the UMNO of which Ali is an activist, Ali pointed out that in a way he, Mahathir, was responsible for the promotion of such elements because of his so-called Islamisation policies that had been ‘hijacked by some of the extremists to almost destroy our nation’. Mahathir’s ‘indulgence’, through financial patronage and setting up various ‘Islamic’ institutions in which they had been employed, had empowered them, particularly the conservative ulema, ‘to a level which had never been seen before’ in Malaysia. Many of them, although funded by the UMNO-led Government, were ardent supporters of the PAS and were, so he alleged, ‘abusing government machinery’ in order to further ‘their evil beliefs’.[4] He accused the private ‘Islamic’ schools being run by what he called ‘religious extremists’ in Malaysia of ‘churning out mindless kids who cannot contribute much good to themselves or to their society’. Such schools, which received government patronage, taught their students ‘to hate and foment violent and aggressive thinking.’[5]
The oft-discussed ‘Malay Dilemma’ is another issue that Ali deals with at length. He argues that the post-1970 New Economic Policy that gives special privileges to the Malays has killed the spirit of competition and hard work and the desire for knowledge, making them dependent almost wholly on state patronage.[6] This dilemma is exacerbated by narrow understanding of Islam as a stern religion that forbids even minor pleasures and that preaches Muslim supremacism and abhorrence of non-Muslims, thus leading to a ‘complex psyche that has many fears to contend with’.[7] Excessive government patronage has been made the Malays complacent. In contrast to the ‘enterprising’ and ‘industrious’ Chinese, the Malays remain ‘backward’ because, he says, they spend their time obsessing about ‘useless’ things: religion, sex, ‘hocus pocus black magic’, and endless consumption, caring little, if at all, for intellectual pursuits. This is not something unique to the Malay ‘Muslims’, however, Ali argues. Rather, he says, in this ‘they have friends among all the “Muslim” peoples of the world.’ ‘In every “Muslim” country’, Ali writes, ‘their peoples are at the bottom of the heap. It can be seen that among the poorest, most unhygienic […] most unintelligent people in the world today are the so-called Muslims.’[8]
As Ali sees it, ‘backwardness’ is thus not something limited to the Malay ‘Muslims’, but, rather, is somewhat of a general ‘Muslim’ phenomenon. Ali regards this as owing principally to the fact that Muslims the world over have developed a distorted understanding of Islam itself, as a result of which they have collectively failed to adhere to the ‘clear teachings’ of the Quran. That is to say, Ali argues, it is not because of Islam that they are ‘backward’. Rather, the contrary is true. ‘Because of their own non-adherence’ to the Quran, he insists, ‘they suffer many calamities. They have been forsaken in this world.’ Ali goes so far as to argue that what he regards as the ‘false’ Islam that they follow, which he considers as having nothing at all to do with what he believes is the true Islam of the Quran, that they have met this fate. Hence, it is inevitable, he says, that their ‘distorted’ religion, which they regard as the solution to their woes, will only further exacerbate their plight rather than solve it. As he puts it, ‘They are also led to believe that somehow they will be blessed in the Hereafter for doing the same things that makes them non-achievers in this world’.[9]
A major target of Ali’s ire are ‘Muslim’ clerics, whom he derisively refers to as ‘priests’, and ‘shamans’ and ‘morons’[10], denying them the exalted title of ulema or ‘scholars’. He accuses many of them of ‘depend[ing] on outright lies to make a living’, of using religion as a ‘money-making venture’. He remarks that the Quran condemns priests for taking people’s money, and that it viscerally opposed to the concept of priests offering ‘the keys to paradise’ and serving as intermediaries between Man and God, which is what he regards the class of Muslim clerics as having virtually become. To make matters worse, he argues, the average guru agama or Malay Muslim religious teacher ‘will likely not know the contents of the Quran’, which is why the people they preach to also remain ignorant of the real message of the Islamic revelation.[11]
If Ali denies the self-styled ulema the right to speak for Islam or even to define it, he is equally critical of efforts by the state, in Malaysia and other Muslim-majority countries, to impose ‘Islamic’ laws. Naturally, he is also opposed to the Islamists’ agenda of an ‘Islamic’ state. His argument is that the Quran is ‘clear as to what a person should do and not do’, and hence there is no need for the state to legislate in such matters.[12] Since Islam ‘has already been perfected’ in the Quran, to seek to legislate it is, Ali argues, meaningless. That would only lead to the shackling of the law, to endless disputations resulting from differences in interpreting Islamic legal injunctions, to the hegemonic imposition of the views of one ‘Muslim’ sectarian grouping over the others and to gross human rights abuses, particularly of vulnerable groups such as women and non-Muslim minorities.[13] It would also hurt those Muslims who differ with the interpretation of Islam of the state and religious authorities, who can easily accuse them of ‘heresy’ and ‘apostasy’, which are punishable crimes in Malaysia and many other Muslim-majority countries.[14] In other words, Ali argues the case for a secular, that is to say religiously-neutral, state, claiming that this is precisely what Islam itself mandates.
Ali’s critique of dominant understandings of Islam includes a denunciation of the conflation of Islam with elements Arab culture, or what he derisively dismisses as ‘desert culture’.[15] To equate the two, he believes, is to completely undermine the universality of Islam, which, in his view, is compatible with all human cultures and is not tied to any particular one. A ‘major cultural failure’ of Malaysian Muslims’, he argues, ‘is our inability to fend off the Arabisation of Malay music, culture, religion and language’.[16] This tendency to ‘ape the Arabs’ by regarding Arab culture as somehow more ‘Islamic’ also leads to a pervasive sense of alienation from local culture and a profound feeling of inferiority vis-à-vis the Arabs, who are considered to be somehow ‘better’ Muslims just because of their culture and language. This attitude, Ali laments, nurtures among the Malays a strong sense of ‘self-deprecation’ and ‘low self-esteem’ that keeps the community down, leading to ‘negative values’ and ‘arrogance, rudeness and withdrawal into racial and religious cocoons’ that become shields to cover up for their weakness.[17] In this regard, Ali caustically asks:
[W]hat is the worth of being respected by the Middle Eastern countries […]? They are without doubt among the most oppressive, undemocratic, poor and corrupt nations on the surface of Allah’s earth. They are hardly the paragons of Islamic virtue that they are made out to be. Even their citizens do not like their countries.[18]

It is not the Arabs that the Muslims should emulate or learn Islam from, Ali argues. Since he interprets Islam as ‘an ordered way of life’ or ‘a good way of doing things’,[19] Islam, he contends, is found wherever this way of life is practiced, no matter what those who practice it call themselves as. Islam stresses the acquisition and application of knowledge, upholding the truth, intellectual courage, hard work, logical thinking, honesty, integrity, justice, politeness, care and respect for fellow humans, professionalism, a scientific approach, non-aggression and so on. A true Muslim ‘has to be a non-threatening person to his fellow human beings’ and have ‘evil thoughts against others’, he adds. ‘This is what Islam really is’, he insists, arguing against the dominant notion of Islam as a ‘religion’, a set of do’s and don’ts, beliefs and legal restrictions.[20] Those who adopt these values Quranic are practicing Islam even if they do not call it or recognize it as such. For instance, he argues the enormous scientific and economic ‘development’ that China has witnessed and the rising standards of living of its people is ‘Islamic’, because this is a reflection of a truly Islamic way of, and approach to, life. Islam, then, he argues, conduces to material prosperity, for God is said to have promised this to those who truly submit to Him.

Why, then, Ali asks, are most Muslim countries economically deprived? He has a simple answer: in the name of following Islam, they actually follow something else which they call by the same name. The ‘Islam’ of ‘the confused religionists’ makes its followers ‘dirt poor’, besides ‘stupid, violent and downtrodden by everyone else.’ Only the ‘more crafty religionists frequently enrich themselves’ at the expense of the many.[21] The self-styled ‘Muslim’ religious authorities are, Ali contends, directly complicit in the Muslims’ economic and intellectual backwardness, because of the various restrictive laws that they seek to impose, their inculcation of a deadening fatalism, their opposition to intellectual and religious freedom, their stern, their deep-rooted misogyny and stern authoritarianism, their opposition to science, and their hatred for non-Muslims, all in the name of Islam.[22] To repeat a point made earlier, Ali insists that this is not Islam at all, but what he calls a ‘deviant religion’. Because most Muslims follow this ‘religion’ instead of the Islam of the Quran, he argues, they have ‘been forsaken’ by God, which, in turn, has led to horrific ‘poverty, violence and ignominy’ among many Muslim communities. Unless the Quranic Islam is properly understood and practiced, he warns, the situation will not change. Contrarily, if Muslims continue to adhere to their ‘religion’ that they wrongly consider to be the true Islam, their problems will only get worse.

In this regard, Ali sees little hope, for a whole range of forces, including and particularly Muslim political and religious authorities throughout the world, are viscerally opposed to any reforms in the Muslims’ religious thought, erroneously believing this to be ‘un-Islamic’. Thus, he writes:


Despite such horrific truths, the confused Arab religionists keep insisting that the same Allah who has forsaken them in this world will somehow bless them in the Hereafter for the same non-achievements. This is the sick logic which they force their followers to swallow hook, line and sinker […] The confused religionists are following the Fool’s Law of repeating the same unsuccessful method again and again with the hope that maybe the next time round the results will be magically different [….] They are hoping that all the things they do which can make them violent, poor and unsuccessful in this life will somehow win favour from Allah for success in the next life. Such tragic stupidity![23]


[1] Syed Akbar Ali, To Digress A Little (published by the author), Kota Bharu, 2005, p.103.
[2] Ibid., p.2.

[3] In his Things in Common, Ali argues that several contentious aspects of contemporary Muslim thought and practice, such as degradation of women, ill-treatment of non-believers and punishment for apostasy, are not sanctioned in the Quran, but, rather, were borrowed by the later Muslims from the Old and the New Testaments (see www.syedakbarali.blogspot.com).
[4] Ibid., p.6.
[5] Ibid., p.11.
[6] Ibid., p.14.
[7] Ibid., p.42.
[8] Ibid., p.58.
[9] Ibid., p.58.
[10] Ibid., p.94.
[11] Ibid., p.93.
[12] Ibid., p.96.
[13] Ibid., pp.103-4.
[14] In this regard, Ali writes, with reference to Malaysia, ‘It is an irony that the Hindus, Christians, Buddhists, Taoists, Tien Taos, Sikhs and everyone else has total freedom to interpret and practice their religion any which way they want but the so-called “Muslims” do not have the same right’, their right to do so being restricted by the state (p.106)

[15] Ibid., p.107.
[16] Ibid., p.100.
[17] Ibid., pp.115-18.
[18] Ibid., pp.103-4.
[19] Ibid., p.103.
[20] Ibid., p.263.
[21] Ibid., pp.233-35.
[22] Ibid., pp.241-47.
[23] Ibid., pp.248-49.
Read More...

Friday, September 11, 2009

Impact of Education on Society


A society is a body of individuals of a species, generally seen as a community or a group. Human societies are characterized by patterns of relationships between individuals that share a distinctive culture or institutions. The behavior of the people is a major constituent in building up a society, more is the education of the people, better will be the society.

At the advent of Islam education was one of the major points of emphasis. Holy Prophet (PBUH) punctuated the importance of education, for the betterment of the society and to improve the living standard of the people. At that time the concept of an Islamic School was incurred.

Other than modern and scientific values, Ethical education plays vital role in building up a good society where people can help each other. Before the advent of scientific education Muslim students were taught Quran Recitation, Calligraphy, arts, dawah and other such subjects. The base of Islamic studies is Qur’an, hadith and Sunnat.

Civilization perceives education as an essential tool to maintain a normal civilization. Learning is a passive process, something that someone else does to you, instead of something you do for yourself. A child attends school with the intention of learning something new, to broaden his intellectual ability. He gets awareness about the societies as a school is itself a society where children from different background, nature, tradition and religion come and work as a group.

Education brings patience and ethics, the most important factors in building a peaceful and healthy society. Read More...

Table Manners Link Found

AlhamduLILLAH, Umm Rashid found the link for me! Take a look here. Read More...

Thursday, September 10, 2009

A Values-Based Islamic Approach to Inter-Community Dialogue



By Yoginder Sikand


Chandra Muzaffar is one of Malaysia’s best-known human rights activists and public intellectuals. Born in a Hindu family with origins in Kerala, South India, he converted to Islam as a young man. Having worked at several Malaysian universities, he now heads the Kuala Lumpur-based Just World Trust, an NGO dedicated to promoting inter-community dialogue and justice.



Author of numerous books, Chandra is a prolific writer, having published widely in Malaysia and abroad. One of his principal concerns, in his writings and activist involvement, is to promote an Islamic ethic of inter-religious dialogue. Such dialogue, he believes, is an Islamic imperative, besides being indispensable in today’s multi-ethnic and multi-religious Malaysia. It is also crucial, he stresses, at the global level, particularly since many conflicts across the globe, while rooted in economic and political factors, are sought to be projected and legitimised as religious conflicts between Islam and other faiths and ideologies.



Muslim, Dialogue and Terror is Chandra’s principal work on Islam and inter-faith dialogue, in which he seeks to articulate an inter-faith ethic rooted in an expansive understanding of Islam (This book is available online on http://www.muslimsdialogueandterror.blogspot.com/). This article examines the methodology and the arguments that he employs in the book to articulate this project.




Like many other contemporary socially-engaged non-ulema Muslim scholars, Chandra seeks to directly approach the Quran in order to understand and interpret his faith, largely by-passing the corpus of traditional fiqh, and making only passing reference to the corpus of Hadith. This is hardly surprising since the latter two sources contain numerous prescriptions that are plainly inimical, to put it mildly, to harmonious relations between Muslims and others. In approaching the Quran, Chandra does not rely on the works of traditional exegetes (mufassirun), whose views and perceptions were undoubtedly influenced by their own socio-historical contexts, and many of who were sternly prejudiced against people of other faiths. Instead, Chandra seeks to interpret the Quran on his own, guided by a deep concern for justice, peace and equality that transcend narrowly-inscribed religious and communitarian boundaries.



Islamic Inter-Faith Theology: A Values-Based Approach to Re-Interpreting Islam and Inter-Community Relations



Chandra describes the Quran as ‘in essence, a Book whose fundamental aim is to raise the spiritual and moral consciousness of the human being.’ This understanding of the Quran leads him to stress what he sees as the underlying spirit or ethical values of the text over its letter. Some of the fundamental values that he discerns in the Quran are freedom, accountability, justice, kindness, mercy, love, equality, honesty, compassion, fairness, and devotion to the cause of the poor and the oppressed. These values he regards as universal, not limited in their applicability to fellow Muslims alone. In this way, he is able to articulate an Islamic ethic of inter-faith dialogue that is Quranic, that prioritizes the spirit over the letter of the text, that is based on what he regards as the fundamental and universal values of the text, and one that is also contextually-relevant.



Chandra describes this way of relating to the Quran as a ‘values-based approach’. He contrasts this with the traditional ‘fiqh-based ‘approach, which prioritises the letter of the Quran over its spirit, draws heavily on the cumulative fiqh tradition, and stresses, to the point of obsession, forms, externalities, symbols, rituals, laws, regulations and narrowly-construed understandings of Muslim identity. The former is universal, flexible, open, and inclusive, while the latter is particularistic, rigid, closed and exclusive. The former stresses justice, freedom, love, compassion and equality, the latter authoritarianism, control, harshness and hierarchy. The former is open to non-Muslims, actively embraces them as fellow human beings and appreciates the common values that their religions share with Islam. The latter is stridently hostile to people of other faiths, or only grudgingly tolerates them at best.



Appealing for this fundamental transformation in Islamic thought based on the ‘values-based’ approach to the Quran, which would also be reflected in the way Islamic theology and jurisprudence are imagined, including with regard to non-Muslims, Chandra argues:



It is only too apparent that a non-dogmatic approach to Islam, which recognises the primacy of eternal, universal spiritual and moral values while acknowledging the importance of rituals, symbols and practices, is the most sane and sensible way of living the religion in today’s world. The values approach to Islam—the antithesis of the rituals and symbols approach—is not only legitimate from the perspective of the religion but also necessary at this juncture in history.



Making a broad survey of relations between Muslims and others in various countries, and at the global level as a whole, Chandra argues that a host of factors have contributed to increased polarization between them in recent years, particular after 9/11. Much of the responsibility for this rests on the Muslims themselves, he says, but he also regards what he calls ‘the politics of global hegemony emanating from Washington’s imperial ambitions’ as a major factor. This latter points leads him to argue, as he does in many of his other books, that inter-religious and inter-communal solidarity for peace and justice must necessarily also require a forceful challenging of the structures of power at the global level, most importantly Western, and, in particular, American, political, economic and cultural hegemony, because this is one of the major causes for conflict between Muslims and others.




This task, Chandra insists, must go hand-in-hand with a willingness on the part of Muslims themselves to introspect, and to cease blaming others for all their ills. In turn, this requires a fundamental re-evaluation of the way Muslims understand their religion, identity and tradition. In particular, it requires, Chandra says, ‘breaking through the hardened crust of exclusive, dogmatic thinking’, and embracing ‘an inclusive, universal approach’. Seeking to pre-empt critics who would regard this as compromising on Islamic teachings, he insists that it is perfectly in consonance with Islam, which ‘regards all human beings as brothers and sisters, imperiled by the same human condition.’ The pathetic state of most contemporary Muslim societies and states, including the increasingly strained relations between Muslims and others, have much to do, he says, with a dogmatic understanding of Islam that negates the fundamental Quranic values that he distills from the text, as mentioned above.



Chandra traces this ‘dogmatic’ understanding of Islam to the deep-rooted tradition of taqlid, strict adherence to received understandings of Islamic theology and jurisprudence, and a dogged refusal to re-examine and re-interpret these in changing contexts. These understandings reflect deep-rooted biases against non-Muslims (and women) and an underlying notion of Muslim supremacism and communalism. New understandings of Islamic theology and jurisprudence are thus urgently required for Muslims to be able to seriously dialogue with others and work together with them for peace and justice.



As Chandra puts it,




The taqlid-conditioned notion of morality will have to yield to a concept of ethics which articulates in crystal clear terms the Islamic commitment to justice, compassion, freedom and equality […] Such a view of morality, there is no need to emphasise, would be true embodiment of the spirit of the Quran and Sunnah.



For this new approach to Islam and Islamic morality to emerge as a dominant paradigm would require Muslims to ‘re-orientate their thinking on Islam’, focusing particularly on what Chandra regards as the basic moral values of the Quran. From this would emerge understandings of Islamic theology and jurisprudence that are rooted in these values—values that are universal, not limited just to Islam alone. Accordingly, Chandra writes, received theological notions and fiqh prescriptions that depart from these values would no longer be considered relevant, normative and binding. This values-based understanding of Islamic theology and fiqh would, clearly, be more receptive and conducive to genuine inter-faith and inter-community dialogue, something that traditional understandings upheld by conservative ulema and radical Islamists greatly militate against.



Were Muslim societies and countries truly committed to the Quranic vision and values that he outlines, Chandra argues, relations between Muslims and others, both within countries and at the global level, too, would have been vastly different than they are today. True inter-faith dialogue and solidarity thus urgently require these fundamental Quranic values to inform, once again, Muslims’ understanding of their faith as well as their behaviour. Chandra does not consider these values to be exclusively Islamic, though. He regards all religions as reflecting, in various ways and to various degrees, precisely the same values. This being the case, genuine inter-community solidarity and understanding must be built on the firm foundation of these values that are common to all religions.



Inter-Community Dialogue and Social and Political Activism



The sort of dialogue that Chandra envisages departs from the traditional approach that involves religious ‘leaders’ from different faith communities coming together to discuss their respective religious beliefs and practices, an approach characteristic of many religious groups that use dialogue simply as a means for missionary work. For Chandra, dialogue goes much beyond this and seeks to bring people of different faith traditions together to recognize their common humanity and the common values that their religions uphold, and to work together for common social purposes, including peaceful resolution of conflicts and challenging despotism, dictatorship, injustice, imperialism, radicalism in the name of religion (including Islam) and the global capitalist system and its underlying materialistic and consumerist ethos or what he calls ‘moneytheism’.




Aware of the growing influence of conservative as well as radical groups that are vehemently opposed to inter-faith dialogue and interpret Islam accordingly in a narrow, exclusivist fashion, Chandra insists that Islam calls upon Muslims to dialogue with others. He points out, for instance, that the Quran exhorts Muslims, Jews and Christians to come together on the basis of certain shared beliefs and values. He also regards the Pact of Medina, between the Muslims, led by the Prophet, and the Jews and pagans of the town, and the Pact of Najran between the Prophet and Christians, as the Prophet’s practical expression of the Quranic call for inter-faith dialogue and solidarity and the imperative of ‘coming to terms with “the other”’.



Chandra critiques self-styled Islamist groups for misusing the doctrine of jihad to legitimize the killing of innocent people, non-Muslims as well as Muslims, including perfectly innocent civilians, something that has played a major role in worsening relations between Muslims and others in recent years, besides giving Islam a bad name. Chandra recognizes the justice and legitimacy of certain causes that radical Islamists champion, such as countering Zionist occupation in Palestine or opposing the American invasion of Iraq. He also recognizes that Islam allows for armed defence as a form of jihad under certain extreme circumstances. Yet, he points out, Islam does not sanction indiscriminate violence against non-Muslims in the name of jihad or preach hatred for people of other faiths, as some radical Islamists claim. He regards this tendency to be a major hurdle to inter-faith dialogue and improving relations between Muslims and others.



Islam opposes every form of injustice and oppression, Chandra writes, and it is thus the duty of Muslims to actively seek to oppose and end injustice and oppression, even if it is perpetrated by Muslims themselves against others. This struggle against injustice and oppression is a form of jihad. Critiquing the tendency to equate jihad with warfare, he writes that non-violent forms of protest and mobilization, are themselves forms of jihad and are often more efficacious, besides being approved of in Islam as well. He cites in this regard the peace treaty entered into by the Prophet and his Meccan opponents at Hudaibiyah, and the valiant resistance put up by Imam Husain to the forces of the tyrant Caliph Yazid at Karbala, which he characterizes as ‘the noblest instance of resistance to injustice, motivated by principle and conscience.’



Critique of Religious ‘Revivalism’



Chandra finds much of the phenomenon of the contemporary global rise of religious ‘revivalism’, including of Islam, deeply problematic. While he recognizes that, in many cases, such ‘revivalism’ represents a protest against despotic ruling elites or Western political, cultural and economic hegemony, or forcible occupation of Muslim lands, as in Iraq, Kashmir and Palestine, he points out that for many ‘revivalists’ religion is deployed simply as a mobilisational device, often used as a means to bolster a narrow understanding of religious and community identity as pitted against what are portrayed as menacing ‘others’. In such cases, religious ‘revivalism’ is simply another term for communalism and a potent tool for identity politics and conflicts. This, in turn, completely over-turns and thoroughly undermines what Chandra regards as the fundamental values of religion. Accordingly, Chandra appeals for inter-communal solidarity and dialogue to challenge narrow communalism that often masquerades in the guise of ‘religious revivalism’. His opposition to radical Islamist groups demanding the creation of an ‘Islamic state’ in Malaysia, which he regards as a threat not just to the country’s non-Muslims but also to his own understanding of Islam, is a case in point.



Critique of the ‘Islamic State’



A fundamental concern of contemporary Islamic ‘revivalists’ is the establishment of what they call an ‘Islamic state’—that is to say, a state ruled in accordance to what is commonly regarded as the shariah. Chandra has consistently opposed the notion of such a state, arguing that it would inevitably harm non-Muslims, women and even Muslims themselves, and deleteriously impact on inter-community relations. One reason for this is that the historical shariah that Islamists as well as the conservative ulema seek to impose, based mainly on the inherited corpus of fiqh rather than on a direct reading of the Quran, is heavily biased against women and non-Muslims. Besides, it is sternly authoritarian and anti-democratic, and for centuries has been cynically employed by oppressive regimes to legitimize their rule in ‘Islamic’ terms and to crush dissent. A state based on the historical shariah would thus lead to tyranny, repression and dictatorship, ironically in the name of Islam, a religion that, Chandra argues, is stridently opposed to every sort of oppression. Hence its legitimacy even in Islamic terms is questionable.



Thus, Chandra elaborates:



There is another equally serious threat to freedom and civil society in the Muslim world. It comes from a trend that is often described as “Islamic resurgence”. Though in their drive to establish an Islamic State, these resurgents, like other dissidents, espouse the ideals of freedom, human rights and civil society, a close examination of their ideology and their performance in power reveals a pronounced proclivity towards authoritarianism and hegemonic dominance. The contrast between the Islam of the Prophet and the Islam of the resurgents is so stark that one wonders whether the resurgence that is occurring today is Islamic at all. Can we call this an ‘Islamic resurgence’ if it does not bring into fruition the eternal values of love and compassion, of justice and freedom, of equality and dignity embodied in the Quran and exemplified in the life of the Prophet? Or, is this resurgence the contemporary expression of some other trend in Muslim history? […] It is [a] reactionary, conservative, law oriented, power centred Islam that the resurgents have inherited and seek to propagate.



By thus seeking to distinguish Islam from the historical forms it has taken and in which it has been understood, and by offering a values-based approach to the Quran, stressing its underlying moral principles over external symbols and rituals, Chandra is able to articulate a refreshing alternative to stultified Muslim discourses about Islam’s approach to other religions and ideologies and their adherents. In this way, he points to the rich theological resources that the Quran contains to argue the case for a true global ecumenism, a universal ethic that he regards as indispensable in today’s context to promote justice, peace and inter-community solidarity and to challenge all forms of oppression.
=================================================================

Chandra Muzaffar can be contacted on cmuzaffar@gmail.com
The website of his Just World Trust is www.just-international.org
Read More...